Kewl, if one had said on April 18 that the finals would have been between Deccan Chargers and the Bangalore Royal Challengers – one would have been considered certifiably insane. In fact, though DC started the tournament as one of the most relaunched of teams, they then relapsed into the losing streak that so characterised IPL 1.0 for them. As for RCB, after the first match, they also seemed to have lapsed back into the same old test team ways. Delhi Daredevils were all conquering, Mumbai Indians seemed to be getting a bit confused, CSK and RR seemed to be the usual motley crew managed by great captains, KXIP were losing steam and KKR had completely lost the plot and it all seemed to indicate that yes, the semis will more or less be along the same lines as last year – ie DD vs RR and CSK vs KXIP. And then a great revival happened, RCB started winning matches and DC also managed to turn around and MI somewhere changed brains and support staff with KKR and they started losing from surefire winning positions and suddenly the semis looked a lot different. KKR staged a revival of sorts defeating CSK in the highest run chase of the tournament and then defeated RR and one started wondering what was happening. Then DD paid the price for keeping one of the most effective strike bowlers out of the attack on the grounds of lack of form and had to meet a marauding Adam Gilchrist, as Kumble showed in the finals, it takes the wiles of an ancient warrior to fell one of the most destructive opening bats ever and DD missed that plot point. Sometimes one wonders if Sehwag captains the same way he plays – with not much of an idea of what it takes. Anyways, for the second year in running, DD despite being a wonderfully balanced team crashed out in the semis. The other semis between CSK and RCB was expected to go the way of CSK and then that guy Manish Pandey and some resolute batting by the rest of RCB won the match for RCB. And voila, you had the surprise finals – the teams which finished rock bottom last year were the ones to clash for the honour of owning that monstrosity also known as the IPL trophy. Mallya uncle salivated and drooled at this – though his so called miracle man wasn’t the South African turned English willow wielder but a deadlier willowy steel framed character who looked as harmless as a rabbit but struck as vengefully and viciously as a rattler roused, one Anil Kumble. The final was nail biting – with RCB batsmen contriving to lose from a winning position. RP Singh looks like a deadly addition to the Indian new ball pair of Zaheer Khan and Ishant Sharma (though the two of them didn’t have the best of tournaments). If only Anil Kumble was in the striker’s position in the last over – Robin Uthappa for his purported opening batsman and rating as a destructive batsman was about as useful as my grandmom in that final over and one could sense the frustration in Kumble as he saw ball after ball wasted. If not anything as he showed in his bowling, he would have made an effort and that would have counted, but then that is more of an if situation than anything else. So DC won and I slept and based on news reports, I think that was a good decision to take – for the monstrosity of the closing ceremony was apparently as bad as the trophy. Anyways, in the propah blogger fashion, I have my review of all the eight teams and will start with the losers first..
Kolkata Knight Riders – the last games showed what could have been if not for the destructive influences within and without the dressing room. McCullum released from the burden of shouldering the debacle of the team performed to his usual capabilities, Brad Hodge stood up and got counted finally, the smaller Indian players pulled their weight, especially in the win against RR and somehow, the jokers of IPL 2.0 left the shores of SA with their heads held a little higher than it was a fortnight back. The KKR debacle also showed the importance of the captain in the T20 game as much as the performance by Warne, Dhoni and later Gilchrist and Kumble showed. I do wish for the sake of the franchise that the deadwood and destructive influences are removed and the team can return a stronger unit in the next version of this tournament. Rate them a 2/10 on performance, a 8/10 on entertainment value (mostly off the ground) and a 6/10 for attitude (especially towards the end). McCullum as a captain was endearing but weak, except in the end where he broke free and played his normal game, so the captain gets a rating of 1/10.
Mumbai Indians – Had the strongest opening bowling pair in Zaheer Khan and Lasith Malinga. The latter’s horizontal slinging action is as disconcerting to watch as I am sure it is to play - reminds me of Abdul Qadir’s contortions. The former was injured and the bowling lost a bit of its teeth. But what was a disappointment was the performance of two of the eternal batting greats – Jayasuriya and Tendulkar. Tendulkar’s captaincy bore the same uncertainty that his captaincy of India bore and I think it is best that SRT play under another captain than try and do be both the leader and the best batsman of the team. Shaun Pollock last year captained far better than SRT this year did with a weaker team. The batting was the weakness with the fragile middle order never being able to completely pull its weight, except maybe in the match against CSK where Abhishek Nayyar exploded in that Freddie Flintoff over. Rate them a 4/10 on performance, a 3/10 on entertainment value (nothing happening even off the pitch), 4/10 for attitude (a slight loser attitude if you know what I mean). SRT as a captain was not much of a success especially in the latter half of the tournament and I wouldn’t rate him more than 3/10 for that.
King XI Punjab – Well, I don’t know if they finished above RR, but they were the 3rd worst team in my book. Yuvraj is again not cut out to be a captain – he seems on the ground to be a bit too impetuous. The team badly missed Shaun Marsh at the top of the order and Brett Lee in the bowling department. The defining moment in run up to the semis was when Murali was running webs around Yuvraj with him scratching a 8 of 18 balls, which defined how much of a stranglehold the spinners had on the man. A pretty anonymous performance – slipping from leading the pack for the semis behind DD to end up 5th or 6th on the final list. Rate them a 4/10 on performance, 5/10 on entertainment (mostly for Appam Chutiya :D and Preity Zinta), 4/10 for attitude. Yuvraj as a captain was average, I mean he did have a decent team, which he couldn’t get into the semis, so that is where the problem was – a 3/10 in my book.
Rajasthan Royals – Well, again a very motley crew – a scratchy Graeme Smith meant that Yusuf Pathan had to bear the cross of belting the ball across the ground – did get some support from Naman Ojha when he came out to play. Bowling other than Warne was scratchy, though Munaf did try hard. But as usual a very average team punched well above its weight, wonder what Shane Warne does with his team. The Kamran Khan super over was defining – on the one side, the most explosive West Indian batsman in recent times, on the other side a new bowler bowling with the pressure on his and he comes out tops. Compare that with the world’s supposedly wiliest spin bowler, bowling to an average journeyman but very effective blaster and guess who won. Amazing, this guy Warne, am sure he would have made the RR team walk on water with his motivational talk. In the end missed the explosive power that Watson, Smith and Asnodkar provided last year – Watson wasn’t there, Smith was a shadow of his normal self and SA pitches proved to be a bit difficult for Asnodkar. The bowling was disciplined, though it missed the wicket taking abilities of Sohail Tanvir. But Warne and team pretty much dragged themselves to a stage where they were challenging for the semis till atleast the last match. They did have the highest and lowest scores in the tournament and so were quite erratic. Would rate their performance a 5/10 (mainly due to the lack of consistency); a 7/10 on entertainment (Y Pathan in full flow is brutal) and 8/10 for attitude. As a captain Warne did everything expected of him (after IPL 1.0 especially) and that would rate a 8/10.
Chennai Super Kings – the team which had the orange cap holder, lost out because of its sloppy fielding and ineffective bowling. In the semis, I for the first time since I started tracking MS Dhoni (about a year and a half back) noticed tension and stress on his face. He looked a bit lost on how to contain the RCB batsmen who were running away with the match. But till then, the erraticness was mainly due to the bowling and fielding, which were never consistent. Hayden was in full form and so was Raina as they plundered runs at will. The others, Dhoni excluded, were a bit rusty, but it didn’t finally matter much. Murali’s bowling was divine, the way he ran circles around KXIP had to be seen to be believed and man was he something in a T20 match. Rate their performance as a 6/10 (mainly because they lifted their performance when it mattered, except of course in the semis), 7/10 on entertainment (Hayden in full flow is entertaining, as is a smiling assassin Murali in full form), a 6/10 on attitude (fielding left a lot to be desired). As a captain, Dhoni was great, but not as effective as he was last year, but amongst the best nevertheless and gets a 7/10 from me.
Delhi Daredevils – the most amazingly well balanced team, let go of Shikhar Dewan who went on to have an anonymous season in Mumbai Indians, but the top order misfired seriously with both Sehwag and Gambhir looking woefully out of form. Thankfully they have AB De Villiers, Dilshan Tilekaratne as he does occasionally when he bats. Not much of imagination at work, not much of thought, a weaker team would have caved in a long time back but the team was filled with performers and that is what drove them to the semis, but then when they had to lift their game for that one match, they were rendered incapable as they did not have a captain who led from the front. The remaining three did. My rating of them was a 7/10 on performance (you couldn’t fault them much there), 6/10 on entertainment, 6/10 on attitude. On the captaincy front, Sehwag was a failure, and would rate only a 4/10 in my book, he had probably the best team in the tournament and couldn’t get them to the finals and well, leaving out McGrath and claiming that was on account of form, especially when you and your pal are still in the team while scratching around, doesn’t cut much ice.
Royal Challengers Bangalore – well, as the tournament started, they began well, taking apart RR in the first match for the lowest total in IPL 2.0. And the promptly lost the plot – the expensive buy of KP scratching around both as a batsman and as a captain for a while, RCB were well, anonymous. The performers then were the two test bats – Rahul Dravid and Jacques Kallis, the latter had a much better tournament this year than he did last year and well, Dravid showed that it is good to have a wall in the team especially on SA pitches. But the real turnaround happened after KP left and the reins of the team were given to the man – well, you can say a lot of things about Kumble but one thing you cant say about him is that he will not fight – the only one of the Indian bowlers in the nineties who had the whim and vigour to give it as good as he got (in action not words) and who hated to be hit for a six. The man brought in a quiet determination into the team and well, all of the sudden the test team and jokers of the year 2008 were touted as one of the stronger teams – leading the team to 5 straight wins to get them to semis and then bowling tightly around the CSK batsmen, not allowing them to get away with the match, and restricting them to a total which his team could chase. The finals was the revelation – as Kumble brought himself on in the first over and took the wicket of Adam Gilchrist and then Symonds, and kept DC in check especially when they threatened to run away with the match. The man was everywhere.. He deserved to win purely for this, though I don’t think the team did.. Manish Pandey proved to be the discovery of this season, lets hope he does as well in the next one. And the test team of 08 has morphed into the erratic but supremely confident team of 09. Rating on performance would be 7/10, entertainment was 6/10 and attitude was a 7/10. Kumble for his masterful leadership gets a 8/10 – I think only Warne would appreciate what Kumble achieved.
Deccan Chargers – the losers of 08, the team filled with superstars who misfired at every instance, led by a reticent and unsure VVS, morphed into a team which was disciplined, which knew its strengths, which no longer had to depend only on Rohit Sharma to deliver the goods. Gilchrist performed excellently in all his three roles – as captain he motivated his team as could be seen in the finals, as a wicketkeeper he was one of the more effective ones in the tournament, but it was as an opening batsman that he put his stamp on the tournament. The semis - the calculated assault on Nannes and later Sehwag meant that there was no way the team was going to be pressured into a loss. Gibbs was again a revelation – playing well against character – though he had most number of ducks, he also was one of the steadiest bats when DC found themselves in trouble as in the finals- ever watchful. The Symonds without the hair played like he had a point to prove, though with his stalking act on Manish Pandey, showed that old habits do die hard. I don’t know if this was the best team to win the tournament, but they were the most disciplined in playing to their strengths and to that extent deserved their victory. RP Singh was excellent with the ball as was Pragyan Ojha. My rating of the team would be a 7/10 on performance, 7/10 on entertainment and 8/10 on attitude, KKR doesn’t need to look further than DC on how to revive a dead duck team. Gilchrist led as a fine captain, would rate 7/10 in my book.
Overall, T20 did capture the imagination of the crowds – IPL 2.0 was a more balanced match up between the batting and the bowling, and to that extent was a bit less adrenaline driven than IPL 2.0 – may not have been too exciting for the ordinary crowd. But the stand out performances for me were by bowlers – Murali in the CSK-KXIP match, Kumble in the CSK-RCB semis and then in the finals, RP Singh pretty much through the tournament. The batsmen broke free and there were quite a few 25+ run overs but there was never the obscene subjugation of the bowler as in IPL 1.0. The bowlers had a fair chance and the good ones amongst them took them. And it also disproved the great Bhookha Naan’s theory of multiple captains – the teams that did well (except maybe DD), were led by very strong individuals who could carry the team with them and who had the cricketing nous to do the tactical changes on the ground which kept the pressure up on the other team. I expect that T20 will take a lot away from the ODI, but will find it difficult to take away from the Test – the T20 is a skirmish, the ODI a battle, but the test is a war, which tests not just the immediate performance of a team but how it lasts through 5 days, and how the forces are marshaled over that period – the T20 will find it difficult to compete with that. And the captain rules.